The Future of Emission Standards: BS7 in India and the Controversy of Euro 7
In May 2023, Mr. Nitin Gadkari, India's Minister of Road Transport and Highways, addressed senior representatives from automotive companies in a closed-door meeting. He urged them to prepare for manufacturing BS7 vehicles and to start researching these new emission standards proactively. Unlike the previous transitions, the government would not set a strict deadline but expected the industry to be ready. The BS7 standards are set to be equivalent to the Euro 7 norms, which will take effect in Europe in July 2025. However, the Euro 7 norms have met significant resistance from the automotive industry and several European nations.
The Automotive Industry's Opposition to Euro 7
Euro 7 norms have sparked a strong backlash from major automotive companies. BMW's chairperson, Oliver Zipse, has called the norms entirely unfeasible. Stellantis CEO, Carlos Tavares, has labeled them useless, while Italian truck giant Iveco has dismissed them as plain stupid. Volvo has criticized the lack of lead time for implementation, and the CEO of Daimler Trucks has highlighted the substantial investment required, which not all companies are prepared for.
This opposition is not limited to the industry alone. Several European countries, led by Italy, have voiced their concerns. Italy's Transport Minister, Matteo Salvini, has openly criticized the Euro 7 norms, forming a coalition with other European nations to challenge them in the European Parliament. Italy claims to have enough allies within the EU to potentially block the implementation of Euro 7.
Why the Resistance?
Historically, the Euro emission standards have progressively tightened to reduce harmful emissions from vehicles. Since the introduction of Euro 1 in 1992, each subsequent standard has aimed to lower emissions of nitrogen oxide, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter. The journey from Euro 1 to Euro 6 saw significant reductions in emissions, with Euro 6, implemented in 2015, bringing stringent controls on nitrogen oxide emissions from diesel vehicles and introducing real-world driving emissions testing.
Euro 7, set to be implemented in 2025, proposes even more stringent limits:
- Nitrogen Oxide limit of 60 mg per km for both petrol and diesel vehicles.
- Real-world driving emissions to be monitored under more extreme conditions.
- Emission compliance for vehicles extended to 10 years or 200,000 km.
- Strict controls on cold start emissions, necessitating advanced catalytic converter technologies.
- Introduction of On-Board Monitoring (OBM) systems to continuously check emissions in real-time.
- Regulation of non-tailpipe particulate matter from tires and brakes.
These new requirements pose significant technical and financial challenges for car manufacturers. The development costs are expected to increase, potentially raising the price of new vehicles by 1-2 lakh rupees. This could deter consumers from purchasing new cars, prolonging the use of older, more polluting vehicles and impacting the automotive industry's profitability and employment.
The Indian Context: BS7 Standards
India's emission standards, known as Bharat Stage (BS) norms, have historically mirrored the Euro norms. The current BS6 Phase 2 standards are identical to Euro 6. The introduction of BS7, based on Euro 7, is expected to further reduce emissions but also presents significant challenges for the Indian automotive industry and consumers.
The stringent requirements of BS7 could increase the cost of vehicles in India by 1.5-2 lakh rupees. This is particularly concerning given the existing high taxes on cars. Unlike Europe, where there are no strict age limits on cars, Indian regulations may force the sale of older vehicles, compelling consumers to buy new, more expensive cars.
Diesel vehicles are likely to face the toughest challenges under BS7. Manufacturers like Toyota and Mahindra, which have a significant share of diesel models, may need to pivot towards petrol, hybrid, and CNG options. Additionally, there is a need for the Indian government to reconsider its taxation policies on hybrid vehicles to encourage their adoption.
Conclusion
The transition to BS7 standards in India, following the Euro 7 norms, will play a crucial role in reducing vehicle emissions and improving air quality. However, the significant technical and financial challenges necessitate careful planning and collaboration between the government and the automotive industry. Consumers should start considering alternative fuel options, such as petrol, hybrid, CNG, and electric vehicles, to be better prepared for the upcoming changes.
The automotive industry, both in Europe and India, stands at a critical juncture. The implementation of these stringent emission norms will require innovation, investment, and a collective effort to achieve a sustainable and cleaner future.
Kommentare